Showing posts with label Bestline. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bestline. Show all posts

Monday, April 15, 2013

It's Good To Be The King!


Unless, you’re not.
When candidates for higher office bang on our doors or send us mail asking for our trust and our vote, we are always wary, wondering whether the person is seeking election out of an altruistic and sincere desire to give back to the community, or whether it’s to exploit the position for personal gain.

You don’t have to look far to find instances of judges, senators, commissioners and even the president abusing their power or using their elected positions to line their own pockets. Chicago has become famous for it, and Pennsylvania has had no shortage of candidates for this Hall of Shame…the ‘pay to play’ scandal involving some elected and PA Turnpike officials that broke last month comes to mind as the most recent example. In that vein we feel justified in being skeptical about elected officials in general.
When a prospective business came to Lower Providence last year to investigate opening a branch on the Norristown Ford property, they said they were met with delays, discouragement and an attempt by a mysterious and unnamed “group of neighbors” to extort concessions from them before their plans could proceed. Feeling unwelcomed, frustrated, and facing the prospect of an expensive and time-consuming approval process with what they viewed as having zero chance of success, they took the jobs and tax revenue they would have generated and settled elsewhere. (Read more here).
It didn’t make sense. I was puzzled as to why any township such as ours, with an eroding tax base and escalating costs, would not make a serious attempt to work with any interested business, instead of chasing them away.  
As is often the case, the clarity of hindsight allows seemingly illogical things to make sense.  What I learned recently illustrated that it’s bad enough that the interests of one family were put over the interests of the entire Township; what’s more egregious is that the interests elevated and given priority were those of an elected official who swore an oath to serve the best interests of the Township.
Supervisor Don Thomas, and members of his family, own property right next to the Norristown Ford property.  Those mysterious concerned neighbors making demands based upon informal plans that had never been advertised for public hearing have never been named, but the description of their location fits none other than the Thomas family. Only those on the inside of 100 Parklane Drive – staff, solicitor and the supervisors - would even have known that  such plans existed.  
The focus became clearer at the March 28, 2013 Zoning Hearing Board meeting, wherein this same supervisor presented his application for a plan to convert an existing garage on his property into four residential studio apartments, for a total of five residences at that location.  Now it’s apparent why the “group of neighbors” with all the alleged concerns about Bestline wanted Bestline, among other things, to provide an electrical line run to what appears to be the same building as that slated to be converted to residences, residential units which, presumably, would be much harder to rent out if a bustling commercial business were immediately adjacent.  
Curiously, Mr. Thomas’ position as a current supervisor wasn’t mentioned once during the hearing. Anyone watching the videotape at home would just think he’s a typical resident.  In addition, since his election, Don voted to appoint 4 out of the 5 sitting ZHB members. Isn’t this a conflict of interest? Couldn’t Mr. Thomas wait until he was out of office to pursue this?
According to the application (Z 13-01 Thomas application), Mr. Thomas was seeking:

Z 13-01 Donald & Denise Thomas – 19 N. Trooper Road, Norristown, PA 19403

The applicant is requesting a special exception in accordance with §143-150 for the proposed change of a non- conforming commercial use to four residential units, consisting of one (1) bedroom each, with kitchen facilities, living areas and common storage and §143-147 and proposes change in use is more restrictive.  The applicant is requesting a variance from §143-71 to permit one (1) parking space per unit rather than the required two (2) parking spaces per unit.  The Applicant is requesting an extension of the six (6) month expiration period to obtain all permits in accordance with §143-170.

As a resident who lives in LP and drives past this location at least twice a day, I had questions for the applicant, as did other residents in attendance.
My concerns (as well as those of residents along Brant Road behind the subject property) included the intensity of use, too many proposed residents very close to an already-congested intersection, possible left turns by residents onto North Trooper Road, impact on property values, and parking issues, which were discussed extensively.  The Brant Road folks in particular wanted assurances that visitors or residents’ second cars wouldn’t be parking in front of their homes which have access to the back of the Thomas properties. 
Curiously, one argument advanced by Mr. Thomas as a reason his application should be green-lighted  was that this is “ ‘affordable housing’ for our community, and while that may or may not be a thing to be commended, Lower Providence already has a considerable inventory of affordable housing. We are home to three apartment complexes and three mobile home parks, in addition to an assortment of town and carriage homes. In fact, the Thomas family owns numerous rental properties in the area, including the Sunnyside Mobile Home Park on Ridge Pike.  One of the Brant Road neighbors, realtor Mary Van Trieste, testified that placement of such rental housing is known to lower surrounding property values, not raise them. 
Alas, contrary to longstanding past practice by our ZHB of allowing any concerned resident to question or comment during a ZHB hearing, I was not permitted to question Mr. Thomas about much of anything (the owner of the Norristown Ford lot had also given me written permission to ask questions about the project on his behalf, as he did not know about the hearing and was out of town, but that was not permitted either).   You can view the hearing (here).  

Prime among the questions I had went toward clarifying another puzzling discrepancy (see story, here), which was “Exactly what business ARE you running out of that location?”  It’s a valid question of an applicant for zoning relief since the number and types of uses on a given property are relevant when considering granting relief.
As I reported previously, Mr. Thomas holds a current township ‘business license’ for the ‘business’ he allegedly runs out of his home/subject of the application. The license is in the name of Earl Thomas Heating Oil Co.,  (2013 business license) yet that was supposedly the business sold to Jay Gress in 2010 and by whom Mr. Thomas is now employed.  Mr. Thomas’ own 2009 campaign material stated that he’d sold his business, in order to persuade voters as to why he now had the time to do the job of supervisor.
My belief is that there is no business use there now and hasn’t been since at least 2009 or 2010, but that he continued to pull this license to keep active the claim that he is exempt from complying with the Township’s trash code as it allows him to select his own hauler instead of – as all other Township residents must - using the Township’s contracted trash company.  At the hearing it was made clear to Mr. Thomas that if his application were approved (and it was later that evening), the nonconforming use that permitted the business will go away and along with it, the trash privilege.
ZHB member and perennial political retread Tom Borai was openly hostile and rude to me and others in this public forum, letting his emotions get the best of him. Apparently he doesn’t like that I write this blog and accused me of being there to cause a three-ring circus.  I guess he’s all for transparency as long as he’s the guy holding the flashlight.
Typically, an applicant asks for more than what they want, knowing it will be negotiated down or that the ZHB will approve something more reasonable, and it gives one wiggle room. However, those same 4 people that Mr. Thomas appointed (Nancy McFarland, Tom Borai, Joyce Clueley, Bob Hardt) approved his application in toto, with minor conditions; Eric Frey voted against granting the application.  Personally, I would have expected, based on past experience and practice, for the ZHB to have approved perhaps 2 additional residential units, which would also negate the need for the requested variance on parking, but Mr. Thomas got every single thing he asked for.  
About that campaign mailer I retrieved from storage? On it Mr. Thomas claims that, not only was he now better able to serve “with my business sold (emphasis added) and my children grown ….” But that he “will represent you with honesty, fairness and dignity”.  Based on my observations, that may well be true, as long as he can protect his own business interests and personally profit at the expense of a business entity whose presence here would have benefitted all LP residents.

Mel Brooks couldn't have said it any better. It’s good to be the king.
from "History of the World Part I", 1981

Wednesday, June 27, 2012

Executive Privilege



It should go without saying that we expect the elected officials we trust with our votes to put the interests of their communities as a whole over those of special interests, and certainly over their own interests. When they can't, they're supposed to step away from the issue. They're certainly not expected to insert themselves hip-deep into the middle of it. 


But that's what it would appear has happened after digging below the surface of a couple of recent Letters to the Editor published online and in print in The Times Herald (both appear below) pertaining to the vacant lot at the corner of Ridge Pike & Trooper Road, the former home of Norristown Ford. I am asked at least once a week as to what is going on there, and is any new business ever going to go there. Well, judging by what I have seen and heard, probably not for a very long time.


One of the letters to the editor was a complaint about our Township from a business hoping to expand here, and the other, a response from its new manager, Richard Gestrich. The rebuttal was interesting not for what it said, but more for what it didn't say; it omitted a significant detail. I'm giving Mr. Gestrich the benefit of the doubt here because, not only was he not the Township manager at the time this transpired, nor present for or a party to the conversations, but he wasn't even living in Pennsylvania at the time. In all likelihood, he was only provided with minimal details about discussions that occurred before he came to work for the Township in April.

The significant detail? This opportunity to add revenue and jobs in Lower Providence would appear to have been preempted by one of our supervisors who was apparently afflicted with a case of 'NIMBY' or, in other words, "Not In My Back Yard".

The original letter, a shortened version of which was printed in the Times Herald, was blistering in its criticism, particularly of the Township's solicitor, Michael Sheridan. While the letter primarily blasted Sheridan, it should be noted that Mr. Sheridan takes his direction from the Board of Supervisors.






I had the opportunity to speak with the original letter writer, Gary Euler of Euler Commercial Real Estate, the broker who tried to get a real estate deal completed in Lower Providence for his client, Bestline Equipment, to get more detail about what happened. As I suspected, Bestline was kept in the dark as to the identity of the main objector to their plans.



The subject property is the lot at the corner of Ridge Pike and Trooper Road, formerly the home of Norristown Ford. Except for a small piece occupied by the Sunoco gas station, this is all that sits at that corner, a gateway into the Township from West Norriton. The lot is zoned Highway Commercial, except for a strip to the rear of  approximately 36,000 square feet, which is zoned Residential. The property  also has the  Ridge Pike Business District overlay applied to it which would allow for the use that Bestline envisioned. It is a continuation of a non-conforming use. As long as the property is actively being sold or leased, the use is permitted. Bestline Equipment, a Harrisburg company in the business of equipment sales and rental, with six other locations in Pennsylvania, hoped to expand to a seventh by adding a facility in Lower Providence. They'd done their homework and felt the location and demographics were excellent in that we are a "vibrant community close to King of Prussia, where there is a strong need for these products and services".  While the asking price was a little bit north of what they wanted to spend, they felt strongly enough about the location that they elected to proceed. They reviewed the zoning ordinances concerning that property and its longstanding past use as a car dealership and repair facility, and felt the use they proposed was consistent, and thus permitted by the zoning ordinances. As the property was being placed under Agreement of Sale, in what is standard procedure in many communities, they arranged to meet with Township officials in an informal meeting to discuss their tentative plans and see what they needed to do to make them a reality. This all occurred just before Joe Dunbar, the former township manager, was fired in mid-December 2011.


Bestline- Shippensburg facility
Thus, when Bestline met with Township officials, Solicitor Sheridan and the interim township manager were present, along with  the director of community development, who oversees the planning and zoning efforts. Evidently none of the Township supervisors bothered to attend; had it been me, I would have wanted to be present any time a potential new business came calling to ensure that they felt welcome and wanted and to know we'd try to work with them if at all possible.  As the letter indicated, Euler and client Bestline found Sheridan's demeanor and conversation to be such that they understood him to be discouraging 
Bestline's acquisition of the property. Bestline felt from the outset that the unmistakable tone of that meeting was "we don't want you here, it ain't gonna happen, and you're fighting an uphill battle". Instead of being welcomed with open arms, or having the 'red carpet rolled out for them' as the Township has tried to make appear to be the case in their efforts to attract businesses here, Bestline distinctly felt the chill of a cold shoulder. Why is that? Why, in a poor economy, with few jobs and dwindling revenues (from which the Township is suffering enough to warrant calling a special budget review meeting just two days ago to consider budget cuts, layoffs, hiring freezes and the like), would any prudent municipality turn an expanding business away? In their own estimation, Bestline expected to add  30 to 40 new jobs here...as I was told, 'these would not have been low-end jobs...they would have been things like mechanics, sales people, and administrative positions."  After the informal meeting, it took Sheridan almost a month to get a response letter to Bestline together, and when it was provided to Bestline (via their counsel, local attorney Ed Mullin, who was retained by Bestline because he had also represented WaWa when they were interested in the property not long ago), it came with a list of demands before their proposal would even be considered.  Bestline was told that there were 'three groups of neighbors' who objected to the plans, and whose demands were enumerated in the letter. The 'groups of neighbors' were never identified, but curiously, there ARE three families with the same last name whose properties border the Norristown Ford property. 

One is sitting supervisor Don Thomas, no stranger to special privilege (see here). The second is his parents, who live directly behind him, and the third is his brother and sister-in-law, who live immediately to the north of Don Thomas. I believe it is Don Thomas to whom Mr. Euler references as having had 'too much to say' and was 'allowed to unduly influence the sale' in his letter above. Were THESE the 'three groups of neighbors' who took issue with Bestline's plans? These homes and this property are within the boundaries of my own voting district, for which I am an elected Republican committeewoman. Both last fall and this spring, I spent a considerable amount of time knocking on residents' doors in my district, dropping candidate literature, campaigning in my own race, or obtaining petition signatures for various candidates to get on the ballot this spring, and NOT ONE resident  EVER mentioned ANYTHING about this project or their objections to it. Not even one resident from the neighborhoods directly behind the Thomas properties or within walking distance of it mentioned it. Not ONE. If there's an issue bubbling up, I hear about it. I find it very difficult to believe that it would not have surfaced if there were in fact three legitimate 'groups of neighbors' opposed enough to have come up with a list of demands, especially since a couple of other, far less substantial issues, did surface during that time period.  Also, since no official plans were ever submitted for formal review at this very preliminary stage, there was no notice to neighbors of adjacent properties required. Thus, unless the township reached out in some other way to them, which they were not required to do at that stage, no neighbors would ever have known about it. Don Thomas, however as a supervisor, would know about it.



Bestline - Harrisburg
The list of demands included things that are typically the purview of the Zoning Hearing Board and the Planning Commission to determine, if the plans even meet the criteria for review by those bodies. Bestline felt that the use they contemplated was substantially the same as what it had been used for over past decades and thus was a 'by right', or already permitted, use and that they did not need to go before the ZHB or PC; the Township tried to convince them otherwise.  It should be noted that both those boards are made up of a majority of members who are cronies of and appointed by the current supervisors, thus ensuring that any money and effort spent in pursuing that avenue would only end up wasting time and burning cash for the applicant without offering, in my opinion, a fair shot at a different outcome.  One demand made of Bestline was to submit an exhaustive list of equipment they carry and the gross weight of each, which they provided. Mr. Euler stated that the former business, Norristown Ford, carried dump trucks, and that nothing Bestline carries is bigger than that. Curiously, several of the demands smacked of self-interest. The mysterious 'three groups of neighbors' wanted:  
  • the running of electrical service from Trooper Road back to an accessory structure on one of the adjacent properties, identified as a 'barn'; there are several sheds and garages among the Thomas properties. 
  • 'lighting to the rear of your property apparently shines onto their property [sic] and they would like that corrected'
  • 'they want all equipment, repair and maintenance to be inside' (a zoning issue, not subject  to resident preference)
  • 'What they are asking is that the entire residential strip be left open as open space, the macadem removed, and a buffer installed in that area, with the balance of the ground to become part of the township park that is to the northwest of the property' (Brant Park). Bestline viewed this as an attempt at 'extortion'. (This is ironic to me, because it's my understanding from a former supervisor that the elder Mr. Thomas, and possibly his sons, initially fought against this park being installed, but now is apparently looking to expand it and bring it down more toward their own properties).  
Bestline - Hatboro
My opinion is that it appears that ONLY the Thomases, including Supervisor Don Thomas, simply did not want this business alongside their property, although apparently Norristown Ford was there before they were. Ultimately Bestline realized that they, along with other "unwanted" businesses the Township is already in litigation with, would be fighting a long, prohibitively expensive and time-consuming battle and in that period of time they could be up and running in a community that DID want them, so they elected to move on and look elsewhere. They ultimately wound up pursuing a site in Chester County.  Bestline is not the first business to take a look at that property. My understanding is that WaWa was previously interested, and that another entity, reportedly a supermarket chain, is considering it now, but I have to wonder if any business will ever be located there again as long as Mr. Thomas has any power to keep the lot empty. Mr. Euler told me that he supposed he would be dismissed as just some broker with sour grapes about not getting a deal done and losing a commission, but he said that what compelled him to write a scathing Letter to the Editor, which he'd never done before, was that 'in the 30+ years I've been in business and having dealt with numerous municipalities over that time, this was by far the worst experience I've ever had with one. I just don't understand why we could not work something out". 
Bestline - Muncy

Bestline - Towanda